A step forward for access to information in Guatemala

The Guatemalan Constitutional Court rules that the data on beneficiaries of a large-scale social programme should be publicly available, setting an important precedent for access to information requests by civil society in the country. David Gaitán, of TI’s national chapter in Guatemala Acción Ciudadana, writes about how this decision came about.


In early August of this year, in a historic ruling, the Constitutional Court in Guatemala accepted an appeal from Accion Ciudadana and found that the data of the beneficiaries of the Conditional Cash Transfer programme “Mi Familia Progresa” (My Family is Making Progress – MFP) should be publicly available. This decision by the Court is not only an important step forward for the transparency and accountability of the MFP programme, but also sets a precedent for a large number of requests for public information by civil society which have not yet been met.

To put the relevance of this decision in context, let me go back to April of 2009, when the access to information law was passed in Guatemala. According to this law, the government could “reserve” information (keep it confidential) if it could prove that publishing the information would be harmful to the well being of the public.

Government institutions soon began abusing this right to reserve information, using it to hide information which by definition should be public. This was the case of the data of the beneficiaries of the MFP programme, which was created to promote access to health and education among the children of the poorest families in the country. Despite the fact that the access to information law (article 10, para 15) states that government institutions must publish lists of beneficiaries of social programmes, the Ministry of Education – which was in charge of the program –  withheld the information arguing that revealing the identity of beneficiaries would put them at risk of falling victim to clientelistic political practices.

Accion Ciudadana has been monitoring the MFP programme since it started, working with groups of beneficiaries and finding that the programme had weaknesses, for example with respect to the selection of beneficiaries that stemmed from faulty census information. Beneficiaries have also been obliged to sign papers stating that their personal data should be kept confidential. One of the consequences of lack of transparency in these programmes is that they risk losing credibility and legitimacy with Guatemalan society, as well as the fact that the programmes could in fact be used for clientelistic purposes.

Appeals by Accion Ciudadana, jointly with the Human Rights Prosecutor Sergio Morales and a national Deputy, Rosa María de Frade, to make the information on beneficiaries available had previously been rejected by the Ministry of Education and the Supreme Court. With this decision by the Constitutional Court, the resolution by the Ministry is provisionally suspended.

Although the ruling has yet to be ratified by the Supreme Court, it sets a precedent: it helps put a brake on such efforts to withhold public information and is a step forward for access to information as a fundamental right.

As Accion Ciudadana and other civil society organisations are carrying forward similar access to information procedures, government officials in Guatemala will have to think twice before turning down an access to information request.

Share and enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • TwitThis
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • MisterWong
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • YahooBuzz
  • Print
  • email

, , , ,

5 Responses to A step forward for access to information in Guatemala

  1. Eduardo Linares Batres 23 December 2010 at 2:30 am #

    En noticia de ayer, el ministerio de gobernación dio a conocer la compra de Q.96 millones de armas a las industrias estatales israelitas militar y de armamento (IMI e IWI); como es costumbre del estamento gubernativo actual, y siempre que se les da la oportunidad, por acuerdo gubernativo (308-2010) tal adquisición se ha hecho sin sujetarse a los requisitos de una licitación pública. A decir del ministro, esto “se ha hecho para favorecer [así] al siguiente gobierno, evitándole tener que correr [sic] en sus licitaciones”, lo cual muestra la proclividad de Menocal al ‘manejo’ de la información. Qué la compraventa fue ‘entre estados’ (léase Colom, etc., del lado chapín) lo muestra la comparecencia del actual embajador israelita en la firma de la contratación.

    Como estado-nación, Israel es el único país del mundo que se conoce que estimula y fomenta la corrupción en los negocios que sus empresas, públicas y privadas, hacen en el extranjero. La normativa tributaria israelita vigente permite descontar, como gastos de negocios ‘legítimos’, los sobornos que sus empresarios tengan que cometer para lograr ‘biznes’. De hecho, cuando se emitió esta normativa, se dieron abundantes declaraciones públicas de parte de sus empresarios, afirmando que ‘lo positivo [sic] de esta normativa permitirá el abundante crecimiento de nuestro comercio exterior’.

    Qué el mencionado estímulo corrupto es de conocimiento general, casi ni siquiera valdría la pena mencionarlo; en el corriente año, por estas prácticas se les han ‘caído’ ventas de armamento en Sudamérica (específicamente de equipo para las fuerzas aéreas) a las industrias militares de ese país. Tales pérdidas de ventas se han dado a pesar de la intervención personal de ministros de estado israelitas, que han viajado a Sudamérica a tratar de ‘salvar’ las operaciones, cuando los gobiernos del caso prefirieron evitar el ‘choteo’. Lo anterior ha sido publicado hasta en revistas mexicanas especializadas del sector de aviación y, seguramente, está en la red.

    En Guate, es de conocimiento general que los ‘representantes’ israelitas que llevan a cabo estas negociaciones sui generis viven, desde hace años y por seguridad, en hoteles de lujo de la Zona Viva, en la Zona 10 capitalina. Y los antecedentes de corrupción de los militares chapines han llegado hasta fingir la compra de donaciones de material bélico que se han hecho al país.

    Como recordatorio, hay que mencionar que la corrupción, como la aquí mencionada, no es inconsecuente. A pesar de la actitud de los políticos de turno, que parecen creer que ‘tienen derecho a hacer lo que sus predecesores han hecho’, la verdad es que en un país como la bienamada Guatemala las coimas, literalmente, quitan comida de la boca a las personas más necesitadas, sustraen medicinas a personas enfermas, roban educación a los que menos oportunidad han tenido.

    Por carecer de la protección intrínseca de quienes forman parte de la sociedad civil directamente involucrada en transparencia social y la prevalencia del estado de derecho, atentamente solicito que se mantenga confidencialidad para mi identidad.

  2. empezar un negocio 15 July 2013 at 12:50 pm #

    Its such as you read my thoughts! You appear to understand so much about this, such as you wrote the guide in it or something. I feel that you simply could do with some p.c. to power the message house a bit, but instead of that, this is magnificent blog. An excellent read. I will definitely be back.

  3. business profile 15 July 2013 at 4:43 pm #

    Hurrah! At last I got a website from where I know how to in fact take
    helpful information concerning my study and knowledge.

  4. Leigh Ofer 28 January 2014 at 1:21 am #

    An events planner need to do it best.

    http://www.6cfzsP4cu9c6cfzsP4cu9.com/6cfzsP4cu96cfzsP4cu9c

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention A step forward for access to information in Guatemala : space for transparency -- Topsy.com - 20 August 2010

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Transparency Int'l, The Task Force and Global Fin Integrity, Noticias De Guate. Noticias De Guate said: RT @anticorruption: From our blog: A step forward for access to information in Guatemala http://ow.ly/2srlt #Guate… http://bit.ly/9IvvPQ [...]

Leave a Reply