Who owns what? Trying to clean dirty money in the EU

How do you fancy owning two Bugatti Veyrons, the fastest and priciest street car in the world, with a top speed of 250mph and a cost of €1m a pop? Or how about splashing out €18m on art formally owned by French fashion designer Yves Saint Laurent? How about affording all of this on your monthly salary of €3,200? These are just some of the luxuries enjoyed by Teodorin Obiang, eldest son of the autocratic president of Equatorial Guinea, in his position as the country’s agriculture and forestry minister, which were seized by French authorities in February on suspicions of corruption and money laundering.

In spite of having passed some of the world’s most stringent anti-money laundering regulations, cases like Obiang’s appear all too frequently in the EU. Whilst most country’s anti-money laundering regulations are based on recommendations made by the Paris-based Financial Action Task Force, countries in the EU are also governed by an anti-money laundering directive set by Brussels.

Photo: Flickr / Pa_Le

The European Union’s anti-money laundering rules  are currently being revised, with new recommendations to be announced in 2013. Teodorin Obiang’s life of luxury in Paris shows that the EU’s rules need to be a lot stronger if they are to be an effective tool against the corrupt.

A crucial area in the fight against money laundering in need of significant attention is identifying beneficial ownership. A beneficial owner is the individual who ultimately owns the funds in an account or enjoys the profits made by a company. This individual is not necessarily the person who opened the account or the one named on the company register, but rather is the person with ultimate control over funds or a company, and the one that enjoys their fruits. Identifying this individual allows an institution to determine whether the source of funds is legitimate or not.

Currently, to identify the beneficial owner of an account or company, banks use a threshold of 25%. If someone is identified as owning a proportion larger than 25%, they are a beneficial owner. This means that in order not to be identified as a beneficial owner, all an individual need do is structure a company or account so that they own less than 25%. Article 43 of the current money-laundering Directive requests the European Commission to consider lowering this threshold to 20%. In a report released on Thursday however, the Commission said that lowering the threshold to 20% may only increase the cost of compliance and create administrative burden, rather than bringing about any significant advantages. This is worrying. Whilst a lower threshold for identifying a beneficial owner could still be circumvented comparably easily, it would nevertheless require a greater level of diligence by an institution.

Another area of contention is whether beneficial ownership information should be made readily available, and if so, in what format. The European Commission’s recent report states that an absence of available information about business registrations is hindering implementation of anti-money laundering requirements.

An interesting development that the Commission could consider is a recent act passed by France concerning the registration of trusts. This act obliges trustees to identify the beneficiaries of a trust whenever one of them is resident in France, or an asset of the trust is located in France. The registration requires a variety of information to be divulged to French authorities, including tax information and a statement indicating the value of the assets. Obviously, such transparency would make it much harder to get away with laundering the proceeds of corruption.

Read Transparency International’s full call to the European Commission for higher anti-money laundering standards here, then comment below.

Share and enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • MisterWong
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • YahooBuzz
  • Print
  • email
Benjamin Norsworthy

About Benjamin Norsworthy

Benjamin Norsworthy is EU Policy Officer at Transparency International's Liaison Office to the EU.

, , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to Who owns what? Trying to clean dirty money in the EU

  1. VASHON MCINTYRE 23 April 2012 at 5:55 pm #

    Please be advised that my name is legally in all capital letters with no middle name or initial due to ongoing perpetuated identity theft.

    Basically, as an American and undergraduate student at Everest University Online-Orlando South, Florida campus; we need more law students who specialize in International Money Laundering to crack down on all these criminal acts and schemes internationally.


  1. Who owns what? Trying to clean dirty money in the EU « Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development - 19 April 2012

    […] the Task Force on Financial Integrity & Economic Development. Crossposted with permission from Transparency International.flickr / Pa_LeHow do you fancy owning two Bugatti Veyrons, the fastest and priciest street car in […]

  2. Asset Search News Roundup: April 21, 2012 | Asset Search Blog - 21 April 2012

    […] International’s April 17th post “Who owns what? Trying to clean dirty money in the EU”, concentrates on the importance of identifying beneficial ownership of assets.  Among other […]

  3. Transparency International’s Huguette Labelle: Can G20 Summits Deliver Financial Reform? « Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development - 19 June 2012

    […] Seoul summit, the agreed plan covered a broad swath of action: from tackling financial crimes like money laundering and bribery, to improving protection for people exposed to reprisals if they blow the […]

  4. Laundering the proceeds of corruption: capital flight from resource rich countries | Transparency International EU Office - 10 October 2012

    […] Office, Neil Clark points out that one of the hardest battles around money laundering relates to beneficial ownership information. A beneficial owner is the person with ultimate control over a company. Corrupt individuals use […]

  5. European Development Days 2012: increasing governance to reduce inequality | Transparency International EU Office - 22 October 2012

    […] chair of the European Parliament’s Development Committee, spoke of the need to address illicit financial flows and tax havens; addressing these would release untold capital for development objectives. TI is working actively […]

  6. Procurement and corruption: Where do we stand in the EU? | Transparency International EU Office - 2 October 2013

    […] money laundering but could also be used to detect hidden collusion. On a side-note: the issue of beneficial ownership will be on the European Parliament’s agenda in October in the LIBE and ECON […]