The banks of Cyprus and the pursuit of integrity

The bail out of the troubled banking sector in Cyprus has taken on serious political overtones as the crisis deepens. During the past few weeks Cyprus has been accused of failing to combat money laundering and fraud and that Russian oligarchs seek refuge for their money in this “tax haven” country.

Cyprus central bank, Nicosia

Now the strongest members of the European Union want a tax on Cypriot bank deposits to pay for part of the bail out. This news has not only enraged many Cypriots, but more importantly it has also brought the focus back to Cypriot banks. The anger stems in part from the belief that the euro zone has a role in creating the crisis. In particular, euro zone leadership is blamed for playing a part in the decision to slash the value of Greek debt – a major holding of Cypriot banks, and precipitating the Mediterranean island’s banking crisis.

Still, among the contributing factors to the problems facing Cyprus is a lack of integrity in the financial sector – a central failure in the global banking system that created a fertile environment for the financial crisis of 2008.

Cyprus is not alone, but it illustrates the devastating effect that this lack of integrity can have. Like Ireland and Iceland before it, Cyprus must come to terms with a banking system that is devouring its economy.

For too long senior executives at the banks of Cyprus ignored the long term public interest in favour of short term, personal (or corporate) financial gain.

This is why the banking sector grew to be at least five times the size of Cyprus’ GDP. In a March 16 statement on the agreement, the Eurogroup — an informal body of euro zone finance ministers — said the “current fragile situation of the Cypriot financial sector” was linked to its large size relative to the country’s GDP.

Banks’ obligations to society derive from the fact that they are licensed by the government. Let us not forget that it is a privilege, not a right, to operate a bank. They are licensed precisely in recognition of the fact that they play a critical role in the smooth functioning of the economy.

That leads to the next question: Where were the regulators whose job it is to ensure the safety and soundness of the banking system?  No one is talking about how they failed in their jobs.

Cyprus is clearly not the first country to face such criticism, which is why Transparency International has the following recommendations for the global banking industry:

  • Forge a new management culture:  the behaviour of bank employees is not hardwired. They are responding to a set of short-term incentives and skewed values that are reinforced at every step of the career ladder, from initial recruitment to golden parachutes. Banks must put in place a sustainable management and leadership culture, together with the systems that underpin it (e.g. compliance monitoring, coaching, whistleblowing procedures, remuneration policies )
  • Sunshine is the best disinfectant: banks can vastly improve their transparency, particularly public disclosure of their business models, their policies towards customers, relationships with governments (payments, lobbying, political party contributions) and the measures taken internally to deal with unethical behaviour.
  • Accountability, accountability, accountability: What has changed? What corrective action has been taken? At every step of this process of reform, banks need to communicate the answers to these questions to all those who have a stake in their proper functioning. This means not only the “cosy fireside chats” with their supervisors, but with investors, customers, employees and civil society more widely.

These recommendations will not solve the problems of Cyprus overnight, but they can begin to address the deeper issues. It goes without saying that cultural change will require a large investment of time and resources.

Carousel image: Financial destrict skyscrapers Nicosia Republic of Cyprus. Copyright: Wikimedia Creative Commons/ Tofabuilding

Share and enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • TwitThis
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • MisterWong
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • YahooBuzz
  • Print
  • email
Karen Egger

About Karen Egger

Karen Egger is Senior Programme Manager in Transparency International's Private Sector Team.

, , , , , , , ,

14 Responses to The banks of Cyprus and the pursuit of integrity

  1. Mario 20 March 2013 at 11:04 pm #

    Dear Karen,

    I have three questions to raise:

    1. You mentioned the big size of the banks as being the major contributor to their collapse. Why should this be a problem for a country specializing in the financial services industry provided the banking sector is rightly administered? And why don’t you show the same sensitivity for the size of the banking sector in Luxemburg?

    2. Does any rumours for lack of accountability or integrity justify the unethical and probably illegal imposition of a hair cut of deposits of innocent civilians both Cypriot and foreigners violating the security and reliability that the EU promotes all times? I believe people forget that Cyprus is a European member state and not a corrupted third world country.

    3. The major hit that forced the banks in Cyprus to request a recapitalization was the haircut of the Greek bonds which came from the Eurogroup and which cost a loss of 4.5 billion to the Cyprus banks. Until that time the European Central Bank rated any bonds of an EU member state as a risk free investment and urged all EU member states to invest in such investments.

    I believe that Transparency International should intervene and stop this unethical victimization of Cyprus which take place as a result of the intense competition in the industry of financial services between various EU member states.

  2. Chris Sanders
    Chris Sanders 21 March 2013 at 5:35 pm #

    Many thanks for your comment, it is very much appreciated. Maybe some countries can handle banking sectors that become many times larger than the economy, but that also means the banks themselves quickly become ‘too big to fail’. Once this happens, they can quickly become too big to regulate and too big to manage. It also makes high levels of transparency and accountability harder to attain.

  3. Erik P 27 March 2013 at 3:46 pm #

    What happened in Cyprus is much fairer than what happened in Greece and Portugal, but not necessarily fair: Cyprus was a tax haven for wealthier people. Europe knew that money was being laundered there, and did not act (so the EC is in part to blame). Banks MUST be allowed to fail if they undertake risky operations. By doing so, the market regulates them i.e. cautious people avoid banks that have high risk. Bondholders and shareholders of banks should also suffer through a ‘buy-in’ (I presume they will if the banks are closed). Basically, if people take high risks with their money, they should be prepared to loose it. As far as the high penalty, I think it does lack justice (the EC should have actually investigated the laundering charges long ago). However, they benefited from the tax haven, and the high risk, so they should loose the money in preference to tax payers who don’t have accounts with them.

    In addition, using ‘austerity’ to pay for banks simply allows high risk banks to continue at the expense of the tax payer, and indeed results in a ruined economy. I doubt if the loss of money will have any affect on Cyprus (although a following back run would). Unfortunately, Cyprus as a country was gambling on its financial future to pay for the current wealth, and they have lost. Cyprus must thus now develop means of generating wealth that are less risky than the finance industry.

    Bank workers complaining about lost jobs make me very angry. Pure selfishness. They worked in an industry that they knew was paying them out because of it being a tax haven, and assisting to create this problem. They definitely SHOULD loose their jobs. (especially in preference to workers in unrelated industries).

  4. Mario 27 March 2013 at 9:24 pm #

    Dear Mr Eric,

    I know we have the freedom to express our comnents and views. However the TI’s space is an area where only decent, valid and professional comments are welcomed that aim to combat corruption and promote transparency on valid grounds. Otherwise TI will lose its credibility.

    Your comments lack completely of any reasoning and validity. Such unsubstantiated and abusive comments should better be avoided unless you have specific facts to support them.

  5. Frank Vogl 27 March 2013 at 11:50 pm #

    Cyprus should have been hurled out of the European Union years ago because of its determined efforts to serve as a prime location for international money laundering and thereby assisting criminals from many nations to secure their ill-gotten gains.

    The EU as a whole, as well as the 17-nation Eurozone, has long ignored Cyprus’s illegal activity and now it is paying the cost. it is an activity that goes back a very long time – I recall, for example, that in the 1990s there were reports that then Serbian leader Slobodan Milosevic had accounts in Cyprus (for example, see The Observer (UK), article by Yvonne Ridley, June 27, 1999).

    The cost to decent people in Cyprus and to the Eurozone more broadly as a result of the EU failing to act against Cyprus years ago has been, and continues to be, formidable. This should be a lesson for the EU’s leaders – it is high time they cracked down on tax evasion and corruption in Greece and in Italy (which are causes of the crises in both of these countries), and placed anti-corruption values at the center of their policies.

    Sincerely,
    Frank Vogl

  6. Melvin Joseph 28 March 2013 at 6:23 am #

    Good explanation on Cyprus crisis. Thanks

  7. sex chat line 16 May 2013 at 5:20 pm #

    Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts.
    Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  8. cheap uggs website 30 October 2013 at 2:59 pm #

    I want to to thank you for this fantastic read!! I certainly enjoyed every little bit of it. I’ve got you book marked to check out new stuff you post… cheap uggs website http://www.tcicustomhomes.com/

  9. xsubmitterth 18 March 2014 at 2:49 am #


    Abstract: Operating theory from the Combination Crusher Grow may be launched within the Combination Mashing Grow, this short article primarily presents the actual Combination Crusher which Combination Crusher Grow generally make use of. Probably the most popular combination crusher consists of: mouth crusher, effect crusher, cone crusher. You are able to select based on the real scenario associated with my own appropriate device.
    Aggregate Crusher Grow – Mouth Crusher
    Jaw crusher inside the combination crusher Grow is actually administrated about the combination degree. Mouth crusher good entire body associated with drinking water width dimension is actually split up into huge, moderate as well as small 3, entire body associated with drinking water width is actually larger than six hundred millimetre with regard to huge devices, give food to interface within 300-600 – millimetre width with regard to medium-sized device, giving mouth area width is actually a lot less compared to 3 hundred millimetre for that electronic pc. Mouth crusher framework is simple, simple generating, dependable function, handy make use of as well as upkeep. Mouth crusher is actually which using two mouth area materials extrusion as well as twisting outcome, rough mashing or even smashed combination of assorted types of mashing equipment. It’s mashing business made up of attached mouth as well as shifting mouth, as soon as two mouth close to the material becoming mashing, as soon as two mouth depart however the material associated with discharging mouth area bit of release in the cheapest. It’ utes delicate motion is actually irregular. This particular crusher along with simple framework, dependable procedure and could grind difficult supplies as well as combination crusher Grow is actually broad utilized.
    Aggregate Crusher Grow – Effect Crusher
    Impact crusher offers simple framework, mashing compared to huge, reduced power usage, higher result, light-weight pounds, mashing when the completed item advantages just like a cube-shaped type, furthermore towards the combination crusher upon combination inside the supplementary mashing Grow, furthermore broad found in all sorts associated with ore mashing, railways, freeways, power, concrete, business, creating, and so on. Effect crusher high-speed effect is by using the actual dish sludge hammer as well as Effect dish come back outcome, construct the actual material end up being repeated jolts as well as mashing equipment. Strong launching about the high-speed rotator from the rotor dish sludge hammer, as well as about the mashing hole design based on different perspectives a few bit of back again dish. Combination to the dish sludge hammer the actual part associated with area dish sludge hammer, for that main period as well as strike the main main mashing, as well as obtain NITED KINGDOM. AT THE. in a comparable period, the actual high-speed rushed in order to Effect dish. combination as well as Effect dish crash as soon as mashing once again, to the actual panel sludge hammer the actual part from the area, hitting in the panel sludge hammer. consequently frequently, until the actual combination is actually mashing to the specific dimension as well as release outdoors. In contrast to the actual sludge hammer crusher, Effect crusher mashing compared to bigger, as well as may extra completely make use of the total rotor high-speed effect power. nevertheless like a outcomes of dish sludge hammer easy to deterioration, it’ utes limited inside the use of difficult materials mashing, usually found in rough mashing, mashing or even carefully within rock, fossil fuel, binary substance, quartz, dolomite, chemical substance substance ore, nutrient as well as chemical substance recycleables such as difficult inside the following a breakableness from the combination.
    Aggregate Crusher Grow – Cone Crusher
    Cone crusher accept springtime cone crusher, hydraulic cone crusher as well as affordable hydraulic cone crusher, and so on. Within combination crusher Grow, mainly upon combination crusher or even carefully college task. Cone crusher is suitable for that carefully platts solidity 5 ~ 16 or even much less just about all informed kinds of ores as well as combination, such as ore, non-ferrous steel ore, granitic, limestone, quartzite, sandstone, small stones, and so on., carefully college task from the uniformity associated with discharging roughness, generally over rough mashing essentials, consequently, from inexpensive from the mashing hole will discovered the parallel area, from similar period, nevertheless ought to accelerate the actual period associated with mashing cone, in order to combination inside the parallel area extruded through very as soon as. Carefully college task associated with mashing lots of rough mashing college task, therefore their mashing free quantity includes a bigger improve. in order to prevent mashing hole might lead to blockage, whilst not growing the actual release interface within situ to make certain that the actual specific underneath the idea associated with discharging roughness, ought to through mashing the actual size from the cone base to increase the entire release area.
    .

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The banks of Cyprus and the pursuit of integrity « Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development - 20 March 2013

    [...] of the Task Force's coordinating committee. Cross posted from Transparency International’s Space for Transparency blog.The bail out of the troubled banking sector in Cyprus has taken on serious political [...]

  2. The banks of Cyprus and the pursuit of integrity « Frontier Markets Compendium - 21 March 2013

    [...] Link to the article: http://blog.transparency.org/2013/03/20/the-banks-of-cyprus-and-the-pursuit-of-integrity/ [...]

  3. Integrity Default Alert: EU probes collusion in banking sector | Transparency International EU Office - 27 March 2013

    [...] week, while all eyes are on the bloated and insolvent Cyprus banks, trouble is brewing in another obscure part of the financial sector: the $2.7 trillion market in [...]

  4. Integrity Default Alert: EU probes collusion in banking sector | space for transparency - 27 March 2013

    [...] week, while all eyes are on the bloated and insolvent Cyprus banks, trouble is brewing in another obscure part of the financial sector: the $2.7 trillion market in [...]

  5. L’affaire Cahuzac: a stain on Hollande’s integrity agenda or a wake-up call? | space for transparency - 9 April 2013

    [...] not as an isolated problem, but an international challenge. The reactions that followed the bailout of Cyprus’ troubled banking system demonstrate once more the devastating effects of the lack of financial integrity. As long as tax [...]

Leave a Reply