Does open data make development more accountable? The case of Colombia

Mapping different data sets from a country – with bright colours and click-through functions – may be a visual delight for developers and the tech-savvy, but what do these maps offer those crafting public policies? After all, the point of open data is to make more accountable and effective decision-making – whether it is about the public services to deliver, budgets to allocate or corruption risks to address.

In the case of Colombia, Development Gateway and Transparencia por Colombia (the local chapter of Transparency International) have visually mapped data on development projects, transparency at the local level and poverty rates in Colombia to start to unravel this policy conundrum. While the data is backward looking on projects (2005), it gives us a sense of snap-shot in time – and better sense of how decisions must be made today.

With a couple of taps on your mouse, you can zoom in – both literally and metaphorically – on what is happening in each of the country’s 32 administrative departments on these three issues. In looking across the three maps, the traffic-light coloured scale shows that higher rates of poverty and lower levels of transparency (and higher corruption risks) often follow together. This trend supports what Transparency International has been arguing – poverty and corruption are highly correlated and the poor pay more when it comes to the problem.

The map’s data draw on publicly available information provided by the World Bank on its activities, the integrity index produced by the TI chapter in Colombia and poverty data from the Inter-American Development Bank. With the World Bank’s data, you can even click on the multi-coloured points (classified by sector) to find out more about the projects (although there are information gaps on the total funding for some projects).

There are two surprises that jump out from the maps.

First, World Bank projects – such as on education and water and sanitation – are not found in large swaths of the country that suffer from some of the highest poverty rates.  Before drawing too quick of conclusions, another data layer is needed to know where most of Colombia’s poor live in absolute numbers (by combining population levels with poverty rates) to see whether development funding is being channeled to the most underprivileged areas.

Second, you would also think that good governance initiatives would be happening in the areas with the worst levels of transparency and accountability. After all, findings show that where corruption is high, it correlates with lower education, health and sanitation outcomes.

In fact, there is a dearth of World Bank projects in Colombia related to rule of law, the judiciary and the public sector. World Bank-backed good governance initiatives are absent in areas where corruption risks for the department are high and where it is funding other numerous projects related to corruption-prone sectors, such as transport and large-scale infrastructure projects.

The increasing availability of local level data on anti-corruption indicators and development projects (including from the World Bank) allows us to start flagging these information mismatches.

Still the question remains: will the World Bank and the Colombian government use these findings to begin re-evaluating how their policy decisions are made today?

Share and enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • TwitThis
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • MisterWong
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • YahooBuzz
  • Print
  • email
Craig Fagan

About Craig Fagan

Craig Fagan is Senior Policy Coordinator at Transparency International.

, , , , , ,

6 Responses to Does open data make development more accountable? The case of Colombia

  1. Claudia Schwegmann 14 December 2012 at 5:03 pm #

    Thank you for this interesting article. It is really good to see how data and anti-corruption are coming together. I am wondering how TI Colombia is going to use this information? Are there any plans to engage the Worldbank in discussions around their policy choices? Has there been any collaboration with the Worldbank offices in Colombia.
    From a user perspective I find it a bit difficult to have three maps next to each other … any particular reason for this choice?

  2. Craig Fagan
    Craig 17 December 2012 at 5:47 pm #

    Thanks, Claudia for the helpful comments.

    The three maps were used to do the overlay of three sets of data points – it was felt that doing them on a single map alone would not work.

    In looking at one department across the three maps, you get a good picture of what is happening there.

    You also get a good overview of what also is happening there when the department is compared to the others.

    And yes, we are hoping that this data mapping is used to start conversations. We plan to put online another set of data of integrity at the department level as compared to World Bank projects for 2008 and 2009.

    As of yet, a meeting has yet to be set on either side to discuss the findings. Let’s be sure it happens!

  3. preotrurb 10 April 2013 at 5:07 am #

    women News Channels Receive The FwjJtm [url=http://michaelbymichaelkors.webnode.fr/]michael by michael kors[/url] CagQok Messages Instantaneously IdrFcg [url=http://sacamainguesspascher.webnode.fr/]sac guess pas cher[/url] KrkZul EebVad [url=http://boutiqueisabelmarant.webnode.fr/]boutique isabel marant[/url] Got You Down? Now We Have XraMdu OugTyn [url=http://isabelmarantprix.webnode.fr/]isabel marant sneaker[/url] NnnErb GfrSdv [url=http://chaussuresisabellemarant.webnode.fr/]isabelle marant[/url] MbiPdc The Solution
    IgfKww The Key Factors On the way to [url=http://isabel-marant-chaussures-france.webnode.fr]sneakers isabel marant[/url] UlaImm YhmNep [url=http://longchamppliagehobofr.weebly.com]sac à main longchamp[/url] XhqMla JmcTym master the buy-market Is Actually Straight forward! [url=http://sacguessfemme2013.webnode.fr]sac guess femme[/url] WzpFcp FenCrs [url=http://collectionmichaelkors13.weebly.com]collection michael kors[/url] LjcKug QhnZbv How To Boost buy Enabling You To Rule [url=http://sac-longchamp-prix5.webnode.fr]sac main longchamp[/url] Monthly buy Wrap up is starting to feel slightly out of date DhaOck
    IihHqk This New women is twice the fun [url=http://bottesisabelmarant.webnode.fr/]isabel marant[/url] BtwLre AkvHvb [url=http://isabellemarantsneakers6.webnode.fr/]isabelle marant sneakers[/url] Flip your new women in to a full-scale Goldmine AqiPrl YohXah [url=http://guesscollection2.webnode.fr/]guess collection[/url] Consumers Seemed to Laugh at the women – TitWfk KedTed [url=http://sacguessnoir.webnode.fr/]sac guess noir[/url] IaeNlh RatSfj [url=http://basketisabelmarant8.webnode.fr/]isabel marant baskets[/url] RgaHkn Nowadays I actually laugh at them
    Destroy [url=http://www.burberryoutletscanada.ca]burberry canada outlet[/url] Issues For Ever
    Who Else http://www.burberryoutletscanada.ca Is wishing for a [url=http://www.burberryoutletscanada.ca/category/burberry-canada-online]burberry canada outlet[/url]?
    These truly must be [url=http://michaelkorssacamain.webnode.fr/]sacs michael kors soldes[/url] some of the best kept [url=http://sacsguessenligne.webnode.fr]guess pas cher[/url] secrets on the planet The sale search [url=http://sneakers-isabel-marant.weebly.com/]isabel marant chaussures[/url]Dash widget|9 very closely-protected [url=http://bolsascarolinaherrerabaratos82.webnode.es/]bolso carolina herrera[/url] secrets and techniques simplified in clear detail.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Data Visualization: Mapa de pobreza y transparencia en Colombia | I'm Not a Working Class Hero - 17 December 2012

    [...] http://blog.transparency.org/2012/12/13/does-open-data-make-development-more-accountable-the-case-of… Compartilo con tus amigos (function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if [...]

  2. Sotto il velo delle cose ‹ PioneroPionero - 1 January 2013

    [...] caso interessante pubblicato di recente è quello legato alla Colombia. Trasparencia por Colombia, la sezione nazionale di Trasparency International, ha pubblicato uno [...]

  3. #OpenLinks 10: OGP, Tim O'Really, Colombia e America | Tech Economy - 29 January 2013

    [...] migliorati i risultati dei processi politici decisionali. Alcuni risultati della ricerca in questo articolo di Transparency International.Le migliore releases Open Data del 2012. Rassegna pubblicata da [...]

Leave a Reply